The Charity Commission for England and Wales opened a regulatory compliance case into the Institute of Group Analysis (IGA) following a complaint by UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) over a political statement published on the mental health charity’s website, the regulator confirmed earlier this month.
“Following concerns raised with us about alleged political activity by the Institute of Group Analysis, we have opened a regulatory compliance case to gather more information. As part of this, we are in touch with the charity’s trustees, which will help us to determine any appropriate next steps,” a Charity Commission spokesperson said.
The regulator noted that it is in the initial stages of the regulatory compliance case, has not opened a formal statutory inquiry, and has made no findings, stressing that opening such a case is not, in itself, a finding of wrongdoing.
The investigation comes amid internal turmoil at the IGA, a registered charity whose sole registered object is to promote the preservation of mental health and relieve emotional or mental distress through group analysis. Several board members and honorary figures have stepped down following the publication of the statement by Group Analysts for Palestine (GA4PAL).
The controversy centers on a document titled “Statement in Solidarity with Palestine,” authored by GA4PAL and published under the IGA’s name and branding without a disclaimer distancing the charity from its contents. First issued in December 2023 and updated in March, the text describes GA4PAL as an open collective formed “in opposition to the pernicious effects of Zionism” and accuses Israel of committing “in effect a genocide” and ruling with “a system of apartheid” since 1948.
The statement also asserts that Israel’s conduct is “aimed at eliminating Palestinian identities and culture, as well as lives and territories,” claims that Israel officially accepts a death toll of “over 71,000 with at least 20,000 of these being children,” and closes with a call to action urging group analysts “to engage with the Palestinian/Israeli situation politically and clinically, consciously, and actively.”
UKLFI referred IGA to the Charity Commission for inaccurate, biased information
UKLFI first wrote to the IGA’s trustees in September, arguing that hosting a one-sided political statement violated Charity Commission guidance on campaigning and political activity, which requires material to be factually accurate and connected to a charity’s registered purpose. In its letter, UKLFI disputed the statement’s legal characterizations of genocide and apartheid, noted that the casualty figures cited derived from the Gaza Health Ministry rather than official Israeli sources, and warned that calling on therapists to engage with the conflict “clinically” risked creating a hostile environment under the Equality Act 2010 for Jewish and Israeli members, trainees, and patients.
After the trustees did not respond within 14 days and left the statement online, UKLFI formally referred the matter to the Charity Commission in late September, asking the regulator to examine how publication was authorized and to secure the statement’s removal. In a letter to UKLFI earlier this month, a Charity Commission case manager confirmed that the concerns warranted further regulatory engagement.
A UKLFI spokesperson welcomed the regulator’s intervention in a statement.
“Psychotherapy patients should be able to trust that they will receive professional treatment free from political prejudice. It is particularly concerning when therapists are encouraged to bring their political views into clinical practice,” the spokesperson said. “The IGA’s own leadership has acknowledged the hurt caused to Jewish members and students. We welcome the Charity Commission’s intervention and hope it will ensure that the trustees uphold their legal responsibilities and restore confidence in the organization.”
Trustees resign following UKLFI letter
The dispute has also triggered a wave of departures from the charity’s leadership and membership. According to the Charity Commission register, the number of listed trustees dropped from 13 in April to six in November. Correspondence reviewed by UKLFI indicates that five trustees resigned from the board in connection with the statement, including Kate Taylor and Gayl McCain.
In a resignation letter circulated to members earlier this month, interim chair Graham Mackay acknowledged that Jewish colleagues and students had experienced hurt and fear over the statement. Mackay apologized for failures in communication and oversight surrounding its publication, revealing that a sentence condemning Hamas’s role in the October 7, 2023 atrocities as a war crime had been omitted, though he defended the decision to publish the text and attributed his resignation to concerns over the functioning and viability of the board rather than the controversy itself.
Beyond the board, honorary member Professor Stephen Frosh, who retired from Birkbeck, University of London, and authored a 2023 book on antisemitism and psychoanalysis, stepped down and asked for his name to be removed from the charity’s website over the statement.
A Jewish member also resigned following both the website statement and an article published in the academic journal Group Analysis by GA4PAL steering committee member Reem Shelhi. Entitled “Monsters in the Matrix: Pathological Social-Psychic-Retreats, the Foundational Myth of Zionism and the Haunted Struggle for Peace in Palestine,” the paper described Israel as a “pathologically narcissistic social-psychic-retreat” and argued that Israeli society is underpinned by a persecutory mentality rooted in narcissistic envy, shame, and guilt.
The IGA did not respond to The Jerusalem Post’s request for comment by publication time.