In the early days of the war in Ukraine, I traveled to Poland as a board member of the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee, visiting centers where we were sheltering people who had fled the fighting. My daughter Chen, a photojournalist, was with me.
After a day of some 16 or 17 hours, we arrived at a building I recognized from photographs. It was Chachmei Lublin Yeshiva, founded by Rabbi Meir Shapiro, the originator of Daf Yomi.
My grandfather, my father’s father, had studied there.
'I will teach you the fear of the Lord'
I stood outside with tears in my eyes. Beside me was my daughter. Inside were Jews escaping a war, finding shelter in the building where my grandfather had once learned Torah.
On the facade of the yeshiva were the words: Lechu vanim, shim’u li, yirat Hashem alamedchem.
“Go, sons, listen to me; I will teach you the fear of the Lord.”
Why lechu, go? Surely a teacher inviting his sons to listen would say bo’u, come.
A teaching attributed to Shapiro explained his choice of that inscription. The measure of the yeshiva’s teaching would be found in the lives its students led beyond its walls.
I think of that inscription when I look at the emerging haredi (ultra-Orthodox) community whose aspirations recently found political expression in the Haredi Public party. These are people who want to support their families and share in our defense while remaining faithful to the Torah that has formed them. They believe that our country’s future is also their responsibility.
For those who regard the community’s boundaries as essential to preserving its religious life, these choices raise fears about what might be lost. Will the commitments nurtured within the community survive outside it?
That question deserves to be taken seriously. But our concern can keep us from asking about the cost of remaining within those boundaries. What if that cost is greater still?
Two encounters with angels frame Parashat Vayetze.
At the beginning, Jacob dreams of a ladder standing on the earth and reaching to heaven. Angels ascend and descend. God speaks to him, promising to accompany him and bring him home. Jacob wakes in awe.
At the end, angels meet him again. This time, Jacob is awake. The encounter is almost silent. They deliver no message. Jacob sees them, declares, “This is God’s camp,” and names the place Mahanaim: two camps.
Why do the angels first appear in a dream, and then meet him in his waking life?
Between the two encounters lie 20 years in Laban’s house.
Jacob leaves home as an ish tam, yoshev ohalim, a wholehearted man dwelling in tents. The tent has nurtured his devotion. Within its protection, he has learned to cherish ideals and to imagine the person he might become. He believes he knows who he is.
At Bethel, those ideals take the form of angels in a dream. But the life in which they must acquire substance still lies ahead of him.
Within the tent, we can mistake the sincerity of our convictions for the strength to live them. Only when we step onto broken ground do we discover whether our ideals will shatter against reality.
In Haran, Jacob works seven years for Rachel and wakes beside Leah. Laban keeps changing his wages. His family grows amid loves and hurts that cannot easily be reconciled. The life taking shape around him bears little resemblance to the wholeness of the tent.
Years later, confronting Laban, he recalls the heat by day and the frost by night, the sleep that fled from his eyes.
When Jacob leaves Laban’s house, the angels meet him again. This time, he is awake.
Now those very angels have found an earthly existence within him. In struggling to live his ideals through the years in Laban’s house, Jacob has given them substance. What he once could only envision has become part of who he is.
That is the recognition at Mahanaim. Two camps: the ideals of his dream and their presence in the person he has become. Between them lies his journey on broken ground.
That recognition is open only to those who step beyond the innocence of the tent.
Building a supportive community for haredi integration
For the haredim attempting this journey, taking responsibility through work, service, and participation in the country’s life can place their belonging under strain. That step takes courage. Those making that choice need a community in which their faith is shared, and the life they are trying to build is supported.
The strength of that community matters to all of us. Nearly one in three Jewish children entering first grade in Israel attends a haredi school. The lives those children are able to build will help determine the future of our country.
Those of us with the means to shape that future should recognize what is beginning here and come together to help it grow. By joining our influence and resources, we can help this community build the institutions and create the opportunities it needs to sustain those making this journey and give those considering it the confidence to join them.
I think again of the inscription on the facade of my grandfather’s yeshiva, and of the refugees sheltering behind its walls. Lechu vanim. The learning within asks for a life beyond. On the broken ground of a shared country, there is Torah waiting to be lived.
The writer is a businessman active in communal life in Israel and abroad, and an oleh from England.