The prosecution in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s criminal trial petitioned the High Court of Justice on Monday against restrictions imposed by the trial judges on its questioning of former attorney-general Avichai Mandelblit, arguing that the limits would impair its ability to establish the facts.
Justice Yael Willner ordered that the petition be heard by a panel as soon as possible, with preliminary responses due 48 hours before the hearing. She declined to grant an interim order at this stage, leaving the restrictions in place pending further consideration.
The unusual challenge, submitted with the approval of Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman, concerns a November 2 decision limiting prosecutors to re-examination of Mandelblit rather than cross-examination.
Mandelblit was called by the defense to testify about his authorization of the investigations into Netanyahu and the filing of the indictment. Prosecutors argue that, because the defense summoned him, they are entitled to cross-examine him regardless of his former position as head of the prosecution. Re-examination generally addresses matters arising from earlier questioning, while cross-examination gives lawyers greater scope to challenge a witness’s account. The state says the restrictions prevent it from effectively confronting Mandelblit with documents and clarifying gaps and contradictions concerning events roughly a decade ago.
Netanyahu's lawyers argue Mandelblit essentially prosecution witness
According to the petition, Netanyahu’s lawyers argued that Mandelblit was substantively a prosecution witness even though he had not appeared on its witness list. The trial panel ruled that prosecutors would question him through re-examination, while leaving open requests for a different format on specific issues.
The state argues that the panel exceeded its authority and that the restrictions have progressively expanded from investigators originally listed as prosecution witnesses to other defense witnesses, including Mandelblit. It seeks a broader ruling affirming its right to cross-examine witnesses called by the defense.
Prosecutors acknowledged that High Court intervention in interim decisions during criminal trials is exceptional, but argued that waiting until an appeal against the final judgment could cause irreversible harm and require reopening the evidence later. They are not seeking to recall witnesses whose questioning has already ended.
Their request for interim relief would have paused prosecution questioning of defense witnesses subject to the disputed formats, while allowing other testimony to continue.
Separately, Baharav-Miara’s appearance before the trial panel was postponed by a week at the prosecution’s request on Monday. She is now due to appear on Wednesday, November 25.
Presiding Judge Rivka Friedman-Feldman and Judges Moshe Bar-Am and Oded Shaham summoned her to discuss how the proceedings are being managed and ways to advance them; she has not been summoned to testify as a witness.
Last Thursday, the judges ordered her to attend after prosecutors said the senior team handling the case could represent her and convey their messages. The panel said a direct exchange with the person responsible for decisions would help make the discussion effective.
Netanyahu's communications advisor downplays Walla's importance
Meanwhile, Netanyahu’s communications adviser Topaz Luk testified Monday as a defense witness, describing the prime minister’s media work during the 2015 election campaign and downplaying Walla’s importance to his team.
His testimony addressed a central issue in Case 4000: prosecutors allege that Netanyahu advanced regulatory measures benefiting Bezeq, then controlled by Shaul Elovitch, in exchange for intervention in coverage on Walla, which Elovitch also controlled.
Luk said he and fellow adviser Jonatan Urich saw social media as their strongest means of reaching the public directly.
“Walla was irrelevant and very hostile,” he said.
Asked about distributing press statements, Luk said Netanyahu had no involvement in deciding where they were sent. He did not recall discussions about distributing material specifically to Walla and said former Netanyahu aide and state witness Nir Hefetz was the only person who raised the site with him.
Asked why Netanyahu nevertheless gave Walla interviews, Luk said the campaign sought exposure to different audiences. Hefetz had promised balanced treatment, he said, but the interview itself was hostile.
Prosecutors began cross-examining Luk after about an hour and a half of defense questioning.
Netanyahu’s trial, which began in May 2020, concerns three cases involving gifts from wealthy businessmen and alleged dealings with media owners. He faces charges of fraud and breach of trust in all three cases, and bribery in Case 4000. He denies wrongdoing.